Spore CD code "already redeemed" though not in my library.

[atomictoyrobot]

Spore CD code "already redeemed" though not in my library.

Hello, I'm trying to register a physical copy of spore that I own to Origin or EA app w/e its called now.

I enter my CD key and select the game language and then am told that the key is already registered. I've not registered this game before to Origin so I'm wondering how can I get help to get a valid key for my game.

Thanks