Re: Worst goalkeepers ever

by Heman_Superman
Reply

Original Post

Worst goalkeepers ever

★ Apprentice

I've been playing what is now FC24 for the last 18 years or so and I've never seen goalkeepers this bad. I'm not great at the game and only get time to play casually now, even so if I was a professional goalkeeper I would be insulted at how bad EA make them look.

 

It's the whole part where they basically can't save any shot that I don't get, watching actual football you see some amazing saves plus lots of basic ones. Playing this game and watching keepers unable to save shots that are 1 to 2 feet either side of their body is just insulting.

 

My overall opinion of the game isn't actually that bad. It has good tempo to the play, most players can actually dribble a ball and turn this year, defending is the same as always in the sense that I tackle or block and it bounces back to the other team 9 times out of 10. Whatever has been done with r1/rb passing this year is decent, but I do feel it's a button that shouldn't have been changed because it has been a standard button for driven passes the last 15 years or so.

 

I'm fine with innovation and trying to freshen the game up but for the love of the game do it with the actual quality of gameplay, of course the whole microtransaction scene of gaming now means most publishers of games don't care if it's actually good, some saps will pay loads of money even if they ship it out bad. I'm not going to blame the developers as it's EA themselves that keep pushing out terrible games.

 

Overall decent game, just the goalkeepers are all terrible and so is the publisher.

Message 1 of 6 (3,930 Views)

Re: Worst goalkeepers ever

★★★★ Guide
@Andrewrg2 I wholeheartedly understand your sentiments. Having played what's now FC24 for nearly two decades, I too have observed the evolution and changes of the game mechanics over the years. The portrayal of goalkeepers in the current version does raise eyebrows. In real football, goalkeepers are often the unsung heroes, pulling off unbelievable saves and being decisive in crucial moments. It's indeed a letdown when the in-game representation doesn't match that reality.

I appreciate your balanced view on the overall gameplay. The improvements in tempo, dribbling, and turning have certainly added more dynamism to the game. The tackling mechanism, bouncing back to the opposition after a block or tackle, is something I've noticed as well, and it can be frustrating.

The changes to the r1/rb button for passing were surprising. While it's commendable to try and innovate, long-time players have muscle memory associated with certain controls, and altering that can disrupt the flow.

I resonate with your sentiment on microtransactions. The gaming industry has shifted considerably with the inclusion of in-game purchases, and it sometimes feels like the quality of the gameplay takes a backseat to potential revenue streams.

It's essential for developers and publishers to remember the core community and what made these games beloved in the first place. While it's not entirely on the developers, as they operate under directives, it's hoped that the feedback of loyal fans like you is taken into account for future iterations. Thank you for sharing your perspective; it's discussions like these that can drive positive changes in the industry.
Message 2 of 6 (3,894 Views)

Re: Worst goalkeepers ever

★★★ Guide

@Andrewrg2 Alisson is absolutely useless. I just played against France, and this happened. He's supposed to be an 89 rated keeper and he does this, yet he will make great saves in games from shots that should have been goals, forget about him saving simple shots though.

 

https://youtu.be/i9gNBq00foM

Message 3 of 6 (3,094 Views)

Re: Worst goalkeepers ever

★★ Novice
  1. Yes they can't even grip the ball
Message 4 of 6 (2,844 Views)

Re: Worst goalkeepers ever

★★★ Guide

@Normandiesweden At 3-2 down I was still in with a chance to equalise and then this happens  https://youtu.be/EQ50EGEs1ak. This is amateur stuff, how on earth can a keeper with 85 handling and 89 reflexes make such a blunder??? He has cost me so many games.

Message 5 of 6 (2,021 Views)

Re: Worst goalkeepers ever

★★★ Newbie

FR THEY CANT SAVE SIMPLE SHOTS YET HAVING HIGH OVERALLS. THEY NEED THE DEFS TO PROTECT THEM

Message 6 of 6 (644 Views)

ea-play-promo-splash

What's EA Play?

New name, new look, same great benefits: EA Access and Origin Access are now EA Play.

Get more info on the change here.

ea-help-promo-3

Forget your EA Account ID or password?

Reset, update, or link your account information.

View more on EA Help