Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

by Jailwatcher
Reply

Original Post

Re: Broken matchmaking. Facing a guild with 60+ million more gp in TW.

★★★★★ Apprentice

Feel free to post here : https://answers.ea.com/t5/Bug-Reports/TW-matchup-system-horribly-flawed-lopsided-GP-matches/td-p/661...

 

One big thread is better than many little ones.

Message 31 of 96 (1,035 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

★★★★★ Newbie
Same issue. My guild has 119 Mil GP for this event. Opponent has 148 Mil GP. So they fall in the 3 zeta for a win / 2 zeta for a loss tier and we fall in the 2 (W) / 1 Heart tier.

We also had to field 30 teams per zone which basically sucked our rosters dry but our opponent is sitting comfortably.
Message 32 of 96 (1,062 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

★★★★ Apprentice
By "flagged this issue and will be investigating further" they apparently meant "we will make it a lot worse, and ask for even more defensive squads at the same time".
Message 33 of 96 (1,055 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

[ Edited ]
★★★★ Novice

We are in the same similar situation, we are at active 74 MGP.. we missing one member.   But then we face the guild of 105+ MGP and we still have to place 24 slot per territory....  this is seem quite broken.  

C869DA02-7CDB-4731-935B-177579E754C6.png
C9F7F482-2570-4354-B2AF-7C847414711F.png
B2D30C35-5ACB-4C4A-9F44-A204F65A78C2.png
Message 34 of 96 (1,247 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

[ Edited ]
★★ Novice

We have the same issue this war

 

We have come across a guild that has 2 lines of full GK/Zarris defence walls.. We dont have a single 7* GK within the guild.. They also have JTR in their rosters, we dont have a single JTR.

 

There is something very wrong with this matchmaking

 

EDIT: Ally code is 686 827 438

Message 35 of 96 (1,235 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

★★ Novice

Same problem here.. Great work with eliminating ties to give much more harder oponents. Now they get their rewards for free. This is not first time this happening to our guild. It is demotivating to many players that results to less activity.. Do something with this, it is long time problem.. Thank you

 

 R2.PNGSk CZ.PNG

Message 36 of 96 (1,216 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

★★★★ Novice

Same thing happened to us this TW, 80m Vs 110m, and to those saying total gp doesnt mean anything, average gp makes a huge difference when its half a million per player.

 

Easy fix, lock rewards to LOWEST GUILDS GP, no more roster cheats.

Message 37 of 96 (1,208 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

★★★★★ Apprentice

@Ashurek96There is no cheats from opponent, they didn't choose to face a weaker guild.

As we often win vs guilds with 10M PG more than us, i'd prefer the lowest GP guild to acces the biggest opponent rewards ^^

Message 38 of 96 (1,195 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

★★★★ Novice
We have an over 60 million difference between us and our opponent. That is ridiculous.
Screenshot_20180305-110909.png
Screenshot_20180305-110805.png
Screenshot_20180305-110530.png
Message 39 of 96 (1,193 Views)

Re: TW matchup system horribly flawed - lopsided GP matches

★★★★★ Novice
Here we're against a Guild with +30M GP than us.
 
Capturar.JPGCapturar2.JPG
Message 40 of 96 (1,160 Views)